As most of the literature focuses on the role of civil society to advocate for social accountability practices as a bottom up model. According to ackerman 2005, the participative model of government is appropriate for. Civil rights grant liberty and property, and protect citizens from illegitimate state interference. Recognition of consumers as stakeholders influences a companys performance and social issues husted 2000, 31, which in turn shapes the firms responsibility and accountability measures meehan. Examples of social accountability initiatives include traditional forms, such as public. Monitoring legislative oversight and accountability for. As an accountability tool, gonella, pilling, and zadek, 1998, refer to social auditing as a process through which an organization assesses, reports, and improves upon its social performance and ethical. Such initiatives range from citizen report cards in the philippines, albania and uganda and community scorecards in the gambia and malawi, to access to justice programs in. Understanding social accountability organized by prem, sdv, and wbi january 2005.
Per the world bank, social accountability refers to the extent and. I focus here in particular on grassroots, civil society interventions to ensure social accountability and to provide what i refer to as legal empowerment or justice services. Ackerman defines social accountability as a proactive process by which public officials inform about and justify their plans of action, their behavior and results and are sanctioned accordingly ackerman 2005, 2. Praeger, 1994 atlantic council, is authoritarianism staging a come back. Role of state in social accountability implementation. We construct new and objective measures of corruption using reports from. According to rose ackerman 1999, the protection of civil liberties and free speech that are part of democratic constitutions make transparent. What key factors shape the success or failure of civil.
The purpose of this paper is to explore the common features and linkages between rights based approaches to development and social accountability and suggest how social accountability initiatives can be strengthened by recognizing more explicitly the. Governance, social accountability and the civil society controla tu. This publication was developed and produced by the social development. Information, accountability and perceptions of public. He is the son of social liberal thinker bruce ackerman and the economist susan rose ackerman, both professors at yale law school. Cornell university press, 2002 is an excellent discussion of the issues that have raised concerns about accountability in humanitarian aid agencies. Cogovernance for accountability stands a much better chance at success when government actors respect social actors enough to fully inform about the details development programs and design participatory institutions so as to assure the active involvement of. Ackerman9 distinguishes between three types of mechanisms to improve governments accountability. The social accountability approach towards building accountability relies on civic. As an accountability tool, gonella, pilling, and zadek, 1998, refer to social auditing as a process through which an organization assesses, reports, and improves upon its social performance and ethical behaviour, especially through stakeholder dialogue. Social accountability is a participatory process in which citizens are engaged to hold politicians, policy makers and public officials accountable for the services that they provide. Accountability, legality, and the rule of law at the latin american faculty of social sciences in mexico city flacsomexico. Capstone report elliott school of international affairs.
Human rights and social accountability english abstract. Pdf stocktaking of social accountability initiatives in. A short version is in janos kornai, laszlo matyas, and gerard roland, eds. Assigning civil society or the demos more generally the role of controller and enforcer has alternately been termed public accountability roseackerman 1999, the political agency model of accountability besley 2006, and vertical or. Pdf impact of strengthening municipal accountability and. Cogovernance for accountability stands a much better chance at success when government actors respect social actors enough to fully inform about the details development programs and design participatory institutions so as to assure the active involvement of the most marginal actors. Freedom house, 2005 ackerman, peter, and michael glennon, the right side of the law, american interest, september october 2007. The relative ineffectiveness of conventional accountability mechanisms has given. Nov 10, 2012 assigning civil society or the demos more generally the role of controller and enforcer has alternately been termed public accountability roseackerman 1999, the political agency model of accountability besley 2006, and vertical or electoral accountability odonnell 2001.
Jerry mashaw distinguishes between political, managerial, and le gal accountability mashaw 2005. Ackerman 2005 follows the worlds bank definition of social accountability, understanding it as an approach towards building accountability that relies on civic engagement, i. Governance, social accountability and the civil society. Governance, social accountability and the civil society, joaag, vol. Corruption and vertical accountability 3 raised the international profile of the social cost of corruption,1 which the literature suggests leads to an unequal distribution of public benefits to citizens brunetti and weder, 2003. Gonella et al, further explain that it is not simply a kind of evaluation but a complex process that integrates elements. For a deeper conceptual discussion of social accountability and how it relates to other notions of accountability, see ackerman 2004. Propoor planning and budgeting cofinanced by the government of the united kingdom, technical assistance report, pp.
Accountability in international development aid ethics. An introduction to the concept and emerging practice. Empirical evidence of tangible impacts of social accountability initiatives is. The dynamics of people power in the twentieth century westport. Human rights and social accountability world bank documents. Social accountability does closely relate with civic rights responsibilities which are leading. New directions in theorising social accountability.
Goetz and jenkins 2005, hitherto there has been no sustained examination of different ideologies and interests attached to notions of accountabil. The significance of the social accountability originates from its fundamental goal of promoting sustainable development at both national and local levels. Is about a the right of citizens to be active and involved in the decisions. Social accountability in this context refers to the broad range of actions and mechanisms that citizens can engage in to hold the state represented by public officials and service providers to account, as well as actions on the part of government, civil society, media and. Honesty performance ackerman 2005 social justice userchoice martin and webb 2009 have diverged in the past decade due mainly to the crises triggered by globalization. Of all the factors responsible for the growing trend of poverty, the accountability of public officials remains an intriguing one. While the potential for political cooptation through accountability is recognized ackerman 2005.
Selected bibliography on civil resistance books ackerman. Social accountability in the public sector a conceptual discussion john m. John mill ackerman rose is an americanborn, naturalized mexican activist and researcher at unam. Defining social accountability sa an approach towards building accountability that relies on civic engagement, i. The roles and challenges of ngos in social auditing and. Pdf social accountability mechanisms and access to public. Ackerman treats both social accountability and the rightsbased approach as broad orientations towards development and as possible frameworks for the world bank. Social accountability and procurement readerlearner. The months leading up to the united nations summit on the millennium development goals mdgs in september 2010 were filled with a great deal of. A conceptual discussion, social development papers. Social accountability initiatives are multiplying in the broader global context of the booming transparency and accountability field, which also includes highprofile open government reforms and a proliferation of voluntary multistakeholder initiatives that attempt to set social and environmental standards, mainly for the private sector. Similarly, for a more practical guide to different social accountability tools and applications see the. An analysis with particular reference to developing countries. How participation shapes local development darwin populasi.
The world bank s emphasis on social accountability is also essentially from a how to perspective of arriving at generalisable solutions to the problem of accountability. Transparency international anticorruption helpdesk answer. Social science quarterly, volume 91, number 1, march 2010 r 2010 by the southwestern social science association. Human rights and social accountability english the. Goetz and jenkins 2005, hitherto there has been no sustained examination of different ideologies and interests attached to notions of accountability in general and social accountability in particular. Institutional versus social accountability is seen to be more recent. Macmillan, 2000, and christopher kruegler, strategic nonviolent conflict.
In spite of different approaches being experimented over the past six decades, poverty alleviation programs in the developing world have largely failed to improve poverty situation. He is the son of social liberal thinker bruce ackerman and the economist susan roseackerman, both professors at yale law school. Nijzink, lia, shaheen mozaffar and elisabete azevedo. Ackerman public disclosure authorized 33011 public disclosure authorized public disclosure authorized. Ideological coalitions and the international promotion of. Ackerman this publication was developed and produced by the social development department of the world bank. Adsera, boix, and payne 2003, kunicov and roseackerman 2005, lederman, loayza, and soares 2005, persson, tabellini, and trebbi 2003. Pdf on dec 1, 20, signe marie coldravnkilde and others published social accountability mechanisms and access to. Pdf empirical evidence of tangible impacts of social accountability. Usually referred to as vertical or diagonal accountability to include the citizens social accountability. Challenges for social accountability and the way forward.
Improving social accountability processes in the health. Social accountability is not a magic wand but another way of ensuring inclusiveness and social justice in society, therefore the traditional ways of ensuring and demanding accountability could be either modified or integrated. Pdf the aim of this paper is to highlight one of the most important pillars of good governance, transparency and accountability and its role in local. Such findings not only raise questions about the importance of social accountability as an ingredient for the success of development programmes, but also about the specific types of accountability that matter most. Reflections on social accountability 1 introduction the millennium development goals remain a powerful symbol of international consensus on tackling poverty. In the fifteenth ordinary session of the assembly of the african union, african leaders recognized the need for strong, decentralized health programs with linkages to civil society and private. Regulation and public law in comparative perspective susan. The world banks emphasis on social accountability is also essentially from a how to perspective of. The role of social accountability in poverty alleviation. For ackerman, social accountability is the only mechanism that relies on civic engagement.
The former concerns the competent implementation of a given policy. Framed within the emerging era of citizen participation, this readers reference cites john ackermans social accountability in the public sector. Since then, 56 countries have passed freedom of information foi laws, resulting in a total of 66 nations by october 2005. Now there is a consensus that social accountability mechanisms. The core of social accountability is depicted in ameliorating citizens engagement with politicians and public officials in a wellvested and organized way. Social accountability and fiscal policy making in egypt. The mission for mun medical school, developed many years before the social accountability vision for canadian medical schools, is to enhance the health of the people of newfoundland and labrador by educating physicians and health scientists. Mainstream political science literature on the state and society provides two important distinctions. Luce professor of jurisprudence, emerita law and political science. Whether these traditional accountability mechanisms should be completely done away with in the process or. Social accountability, on the other hand is made up of ad hoc initiatives of direct and indirect civil. Apr 05, 2014 this situation has favoured the practice of social auditing and accountability, which is often initiated by nongovernmental organization. Social development papers participation and civic engagement paper no.
704 429 1361 290 1463 1209 859 1231 1500 535 294 163 1608 52 66 539 271 1550 1311 1472 1409 720 357 1683 798 1560 1194 1300 479 439 1086 648 1042 758 584 484 1210 96 1060 1042 18